Does Foursquare need to change to be successful?
We love looking for the Next Big Thing. Social-media enthusiasts of all stripes love scanning the Web for hints of what’s to come — for the next social technology that will take us all by storm.
A lot of social pundits are pumped up about the potential of location-based networks such as Foursquare — yet as Caroline McCarthy points out in the lead story from today’s SmartBrief on Social Media, these networks have some pretty significant limitations.
I think McCarthy is dead-on in her analysis of the hurdles these networks have to overcome if they want to be the Next Big Thing. But what if they don’t want to be Big? What if they just want to be What’s Next?
Not every burger shack needs to be the next McDonald’s to be considered successful. Not every retailer needs to be Wal-Mart. Not every software developer needs to be Microsoft. Yet when it comes to the social Web, there’s a sense that anything short of total ubiquity is a kind of failing. We’ve seen so many giants born in the last 10 years that we’re starting to forget how abnormal that really is in the business world.
Foursquare doesn’t have to replace Twitter — or anything else — to be a success. It’s playing a different game, one that caters to a naturally smaller audience. It’s not for every person, or every business. And that’s really OK. If it tried to appeal to everyone by becoming more like Facebook or some other network, there’s a good chance it would ruin the utility it already has. Sometimes, having a strong draw for a specific audience can be the most powerful thing a brand can have.
It’s better for the network to develop its user base organically, focusing on better serving the kinds of people it does attract. Niche communities can be prosperous without being everywhere; they can be What’s Next without being Big.
What do you think? Do location-based networks need to become more mainstream to be successful? Do social networks need to be large to be important? Are location-based networks overrated?
Image credit, Eric Isselée, via Shutterstock
Related posts:
Tags: branding, foursquare, growth, location-based, social media
Categories: Editor's Take
Permalink
Posted by Howard Burkat on April 20th, 2010 at 5:16 pm
Boy is it a treat to read someone who – rightly or wrongly as to her conclusions – isn't swallowing every piece of hype the NY Times chooses to feed us. This is a niche product…a terrific one…but still a niche.
Posted by uberVU - social comments on April 20th, 2010 at 11:32 am
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by IAmLovable: pls comment! Does Foursquare need to change to be successful?: We love looking for.. http://bit.ly/d4Y3xs...
Posted by How To Use Foursquare For Your Business on April 20th, 2010 at 11:32 pm
[...] Does Foursquare need to change to be successful? (smartblogs.com) SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: "How To Use Foursquare For Your Business", url: "http://socialmediaphilippines.com/how-to-use-foursquare-for-your-business/" }); Viewed 1 time by 1 viewer Hello there!If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribe to the RSS feed for updates on this topic. [...]
Posted by Leanda Jane Guy on April 21st, 2010 at 10:20 am
Hi Fascinating article! Just launched what we hope will be the next big thing….A community based social network based on what you love! Please do check it out. It's a continuing work in progress and the best is yet to come but would very much be grateful if you could take the time to have a lookhttp://www.myfj.com link to what you love. Anywhere in the world! Sorry tried to send private email but could only get u via the comment box!
Kindest regards Leanda Jane Guy, myfj.com
Posted by Josh Levine on April 21st, 2010 at 4:46 pm
It would be great if Foursquare just worked.
It has gotten better, but for the most part it takes too long to use, crashes too often, and has too many duplicates or venues missing.
The idea of launching before all the kinks are worked out has its merits, and early adopters are used to products that are buggy. But as the speed of adoption increases, so too must the speed of optimization. Foursquare needs to step it up if it’s really going to be the next big thing.