Pitfalls of intrusive advertising: The Facebook “Test”
By Rob Birgfeld on February 23rd, 2009 | 10482 comments on this posthttp%3A%2F%2Fsmartblogs.com%2Fsocial-media%2F2009%2F02%2F23%2Fpitfalls-of-intrusive-advertising-facebook-test%2FPitfalls+of+intrusive+advertising%3A+The+Facebook+%22Test%222009-02-23+15%3A07%3A22Rob+Birgfeldhttp%3A%2F%2Fsmartblogs.com%2Fsocialmedia%2F%3Fp%3D1048
While testing out a couple of Facebook applications yesterday, I came upon a few advertising approaches that I found disturbing. While installing the application, there were various ads that included Facebook action icons. Here I am, a typical Facebook user, in the middle of adding an application to my account (most likely something that would warm the hearts of Facebook execs) and I’m being diverted by advertising suggesting action is necessary. After a little research, it appeared as though Facebook is in the midst of testing out an ad network for applications.

Just to check, I clicked to see which of my three friends “think I’m dumb”—and I was taken to a third party trivia site. The key to this experience, however, was not that I never got to the bottom of just who thinks I’m dumb. It was the fact that I never finished installing that application.
At what point does Facebook regulate the types of advertising that occurs on their site? Or should it be left to the application developer? Facebook is undoubtedly searching for consistent revenue, and advertising conversions are a key part of that. But when an advertisement derails user experience, is it worth it? Facebook, like any growing company is most likely testing and adjusting on the fly—so we’ll wait and see what comes out of this “test.”
In social media, the customer has to remain top of mind at all time. Your customer’s willingness to pass along your product or message is not something to be toyed with. There’s a fine line between addressing revenue needs and compromising the integrity of a product. The key is finding something that enhances both. That reminds me — back to that application.
Related Posts
- Gary Vaynerchuk explains why small-business owners need to stop debating social media and start using it
- How Oxygenics is using a Facebook contest to pump up its Facebook fan base
- Andy’s Answers: How Yahoo! earned 1 million Facebook fans for Yahoo! Movies
- The value of social media customers
- The quiet person’s guide to getting people talking online
Twitter
Facebook
Linkedin
RSS





I see those all the time, along with the ads that ensure me that 95% of users can't count the number of eyes in a picture or don't know how many states there are in the United States.
I had EXACTLY the same reaction. Facebook is one of the most visited and stickiest (visitors stay on the site for hours) web properties out there. I think stuff like this pushes people away from that platform more than will be made up for by ad revenue. Facebook would do themselves a favor by being more careful. As we all know, users are fickle. The Google model is less intrusive, therefor, probably works better for everyone, advertiser, website and users alike.